---
title: Challenging Diversification
author: Brandon Grundy, CFP®
---

# Challenging Diversification

17

Nov, 2026

By now we’ve all probably heard about the ouster of Nvidia’s CEO, Jensen Huang. The revelations and other details leading to his abrupt resignation last week have been covered at length by others, so I won’t bore you with that here. Instead, let’s think about this situation as a practical example of why diversification matters and look at ways to go about achieving it.



Nvidia’s rise from Silicon Valley startup to (for a time) the largest publicly traded company in the world is also well documented. Rates of return for the stock have been massive. Nearly 45,000% since 2000 and over 1,000% since ChatGPT was released four years ago. But then the stock was down 14% last week and 30% over the past month. Long-term holders might take that in stride since there have been other large drawdowns in the stock’s history, but more recent entrants could be seeing large losses. And lots of volatility, about 3x the typical up and down movement of the S&P 500.



But most investors don’t hold Nvidia directly. Instead, they own it indirectly within mutual funds and ETFs. Roughly 80% of Nvidia’s common stock is held by institutions like Blackrock, Vanguard, State Street, and Fidelity, with probably the bulk of that showing up within broad market index funds. And since most of those funds are organized by market capitalization, stocks that grow dramatically like Nvidia do so in proportion to other stocks in the index. This can seem like a blessing when times are good but if left unchecked, can also seem like a devilish curse when the market turns on you.   



We’ve discussed portfolio concentration issues before, and how important it is to get beyond the label and be intentional about exposures within your portfolio. For example, at its peak this past Spring Nvidia’s stock occupied nearly 9% of the S&P 500’s weighting, meaning that if all your 401(k) was invested in a US stock index fund, a chunk of that was invested in Nvidia whether you wanted to or not. That boosted returns for a while, as did further concentrations in the Tech sector from companies like Apple and Microsoft. But as your portfolio grew more concentrated it also grew less diversified, and downside risk grew along with it.



This dilemma is what makes portfolio construction and maintenance so challenging. Software helps with analysis, but making real-world decisions is often complicated.



During my 25yr career I’ve used a three-tier framework to manage a client’s exposure to an individual stock.



The first tier is maintaining less than 3% of the portfolio balance (across all accounts combined) in any one stock. This is probably the ideal in that it implies broad diversification across countries, sectors, company size and style, and the inclusion of fixed income investments like bonds. For example, if your portfolio was 100% invested in the iShares All Country World Index ETF you’d still have (as of yesterday) 5% of your portfolio in Apple and almost as much in Nvidia and Microsoft. A simple way to water that down to 3% or less is to put 40% of the portfolio value into the iShares Core US Aggregate Bond ETF. Again, this is a “textbook” attempt at getting market returns while essentially diversifying away the risk of any one company’s (or one CEO’s) issues harming you too much.



But the second tier is more realistic these days, which is trying to cap exposure at 5%. I say realistic, because the All Country World index has around 40% of its balance in foreign stocks. That’s too high for a variety of reasons. Once you start trimming that back by adding US-specific funds or eliminating the ACWI entirely, you immediately see weightings to the big US Tech companies grow larger. Currently, for the S&P that’s about 8% in Apple, with 6% in Nvidia and essentially the same for Microsoft. Add in a US “growth” fund and you’d drive these numbers higher still. As with the 3% example above, you can reduce overall exposure by adding bonds, but how much do you need? Is it enough to get back below the 3% threshold? Sometimes higher exposure to these and other Tech-related stocks is a risk you’re willing to take and because we have options to manage it. But how much is too much?



That brings us to tier three, which is trying to maintain a hard cap at one stock not making up more than 10% of a client’s portfolio (again, across all accounts combined). Partly, this 10% figure comes from the regulatory definition of when a mutual fund is considered “diversified”, but it’s also a good round number to have as a ceiling. Having more than 10% in one stock can help build a sizeable nest egg and its outsized growth is a wonderful problem to have, but risk compounds over time.  



Still, concentrated stock positions are pretty common and usually have to do with taxes. Perhaps an investor has owned shares for a long time outside of a tax-deferred retirement account and selling shares would come with a big capital gains tax bill. Short of simply accepting the tax bill as a cost of being diversified, what should an investor do?



Often a prudent approach is to build around the concentrated stock position. This could mean buying diversified funds beyond the one company’s industry or sector, such as from traditionally less correlated sectors like Energy or Utilities if you’re trying to work around a Tech stock. Or you could add an S&P 500 index fund that evenly spreads exposure across all 500 stocks in the index instead of by market weight. Another option is to ensure you have appropriate amounts of cash and bonds to ride out market downturns. You could plan to sell shares of the concentrated stock for cash while managing the year-to-year tax implications. And a categorically different option is to give shares of the concentrated position to charity, even to family and friends. Or you can mix and match these options to methodically wind down a large position.



Ultimately, long-term investing is all about taking risks while trying to cover all your bases. This usually entails deciding between competing priorities, which is rarely simple or easy, but we should still be intentional about it.  



Have questions? Ask us. We can help.

- [Financial Planning](https://ridgeviewfp.com/index.php?option=com_tags&view=tag&id[0]=5:financial-planning), [Investing & Markets](https://ridgeviewfp.com/index.php?option=com_tags&view=tag&id[0]=6:investing)

![](https://ridgeviewfp.com/media/yootheme/cache/c2/brandon_grundy-c28cb604.jpg)

Brandon Grundy, CFP®

Founder and Principal of Ridgeview Financial Planning

## Popular Articles

[See all](https://ridgeviewfp.com/index.php?Itemid=117)

### [When Good News is Bad News](https://ridgeviewfp.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=57:when-good-news-is-bad-news&catid=8)

14 January 2025

Before beginning I have to take a moment to comment on the fires raging in SoCa…

[Read more](https://ridgeviewfp.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=57:when-good-news-is-bad-news&catid=8)

### [Stashing Cash](https://ridgeviewfp.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=65:stashing-cash&catid=8)

22 October 2023

Over the past several weeks we covered a handful of year-end considerations wit…

[Read more](https://ridgeviewfp.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=65:stashing-cash&catid=8)

### [Falling Consumer Sentiment](https://ridgeviewfp.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=51:falling-consumer-sentiment&catid=8)

25 February 2025

Good morning. I hope your week is going well. Before we get started I wanted to…

[Read more](https://ridgeviewfp.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=51:falling-consumer-sentiment&catid=8)
